A Healthy Civic Network Creates More Value Than It Captures
In a recent conversation, Tim O’Reilly made a point that has been sticking with me. If you don’t know O’Reilly, he is one of those people who has been around the technology world long enough to have helped shape how the industry thinks about open source software and Web 2.0. He has spent decades watching technologies move from interesting experiments to systems that reshape industries and everyday life, and he is usually worth listening to when he starts noticing a pattern.
The pattern he was talking about this time was value extraction.
Companies often become successful by creating something people genuinely want. A product solves a problem, makes an existing task easier, connects people who could not easily connect before, or opens up some new possibility. The value proposition is what brings people in.
Then, somewhere along the way, the relationship can change.
Once a company has accumulated enough users, market position, data, relationships, or dependence, it becomes tempting to capture more of the value moving through the system. The service that was built around the customer starts asking more from the customer. Prices rise. Lock-in increases. The useful thing someone originally came for gets harder to reach because the company has found another behavior that produces more revenue.
O’Reilly points to Instagram as an easy example. People joined to see what friends and family were doing. Once those relationships were established inside the platform, Meta had more freedom to decide what appeared in front of people and increasingly shape the experience around what created value for the company.
His concerns about AI are broader and, frankly, darker. The AI industry is spending enormous amounts of money to make these systems indispensable before anyone has really answered what the mature economic model looks like, who captures the gains, what happens to displaced workers, or how value keeps circulating if the technology concentrates wealth and productive capacity in fewer hands. O’Reilly’s worry is that once companies establish their position, the pressure will shift toward lock-in, higher prices, worse results, and other forms of extraction. In his formulation, the healthier principle is to create more value than you capture.
We are already confronting this and other downsides of the AI story through the Stop Bad Data Centers work growing out of the Halt the Harm Network. So there are plenty of reasons for us to pay attention to what happens as AI moves from an emerging technology into a much larger economic and physical system. But what caught our attention in O’Reilly’s argument was a principle that reaches beyond AI.
What happens when we apply the same test to civic life?
People put enormous value into our civic systems. They contribute time, knowledge, relationships, trust, money, votes, local experience, organizing skill, professional expertise, and attention. Healthy civic networks should do more than collect those contributions. They should make the people participating more capable by helping them find one another, gain access to resources and knowledge, and combine what each person knows or can do into something more powerful than any of them could produce alone.
That raises a fairly simple question with some uncomfortable implications: Are our civic systems still creating more value for the people who participate in them than they capture from those people?
Civic life is also a value exchange
The value people bring into civic life does not become more useful simply because they participate. What matters is whether the system helps those contributions travel, connect, and combine with what other people know and can do.
Some of that exchange happens through formal structures such as organizations, campaigns, coalitions, and volunteer roles. Much of it is less visible. Someone makes an introduction that changes the direction of a campaign. A local leader shares experience that saves another community months of trial and error. An organizer connects someone with technical expertise they would never have found on their own. These exchanges are difficult to capture in conventional measures of participation, but they are often where a network creates some of its greatest value.
That reciprocal exchange has always been central to how we think about network building at Netcentric Campaigns. A strong network does more than gather people around a common issue. It creates pathways through which knowledge, relationships, resources, and opportunities can move. The result should be that participants can reach more, know more, and accomplish more together than they could through their individual organizations or relationships alone.
Healthy networks make those contributions more valuable by connecting them. Someone brings knowledge of what is happening in one community and gains access to expertise developed somewhere else. An organization contributes to a relationship and becomes connected to relationships held throughout a larger network. Experience from one campaign can become useful to people confronting a similar problem months or years later.
Civic organizations are understandably accustomed to measuring the other side of the equation: how many people joined, donated, signed, volunteered, opened an email, or turned out. Those are necessary operating measures, but they tell us mostly what people have contributed to the institution.
A network perspective adds another question: what did participation make possible for them that was not possible before?
That question matters because the balance between those two sides of the exchange can change.
When participation becomes something to harvest
Value extraction in civic life rarely looks as obvious as a higher subscription price or an advertising-heavy social media feed.
Often it grows out of normal institutional pressures. An advocacy organization needs to demonstrate membership, a campaign needs donations, a political organization needs votes, a nonprofit needs people to respond to its calls to action, and a foundation needs evidence that its strategy is producing measurable results. Communications teams need attention because attention helps everything else happen.
Over time, institutions can become extremely sophisticated at extracting those forms of participation. The email system gets better at knowing when to ask for another donation. Digital programs learn which language generates the highest response rate. Campaigns identify which supporters can be activated repeatedly. People become names in a CRM, audiences in an advertising system, signatures beneath a petition, or turnout targets in a mobilization plan.
None of those practices is inherently unhealthy. Organizations need resources, and organized civic action requires mobilization.
The network begins to thin out when the exchange becomes increasingly one-directional. A person may be asked repeatedly for money, signatures, shares, votes, or attention while gaining few new relationships, little access to useful knowledge, and almost no opportunity to contribute what they know or shape the strategy.
The institution can continue generating activity. It may even become quite good at it. But it is capturing participation without creating much additional civic capacity in return.
That distinction matters because civic life cannot be sustained indefinitely through extraction.
There needs to be some accumulation on the participant’s side of the exchange: stronger relationships, better knowledge, greater agency, more confidence, access to useful resources, a clearer sense of how decisions are made, or the ability to initiate something rather than merely respond.
In healthy advocacy networks, we can often see this exchange clearly.
Suppose a local organizer is facing an unfamiliar industrial proposal. They bring knowledge of the community, the decision makers, the local history, the permitting process, and the people likely to be affected. Through the network, they might gain access to someone who has fought the same developer elsewhere, technical research they would never have commissioned themselves, communications experience from a previous campaign, legal interpretation, data, media relationships, or connections to other communities facing similar problems.
Their local knowledge becomes more useful because it enters a network. The network becomes more useful because their local knowledge entered it.
That reciprocal increase in capacity is one of the clearest signs that a network is creating value rather than merely collecting participants.
We have privatized much of the way people navigate civic life
There is another layer to the problem.
Civic life contains tremendous amounts of distributed knowledge, relationships, expertise, and institutional capacity. The challenge is connecting people to the right pieces of that capacity when they need them.
Healthy networks are designed to solve exactly this problem. They make relationships more visible, help knowledge travel, and create pathways through which people can find resources beyond their immediate organization or circle. Across American civic life, however, much of that connective infrastructure is fragmented, and an increasing share of the systems we use to navigate it are privately owned.
People discover organizations through search engines. They encounter political information in algorithmic feeds. They find communities through Facebook groups, Reddit threads, WhatsApp chats, Discord servers, Instagram accounts, TikTok videos, email platforms, and whatever other communications systems happen to connect the people they know.
These services create real value. There is little point pretending otherwise. Many civic relationships would not exist without them.
But the incentives governing those systems are different from the needs of the civic life that increasingly runs through them.
A platform does not have to help someone understand the ecosystem of organizations working on housing in their county, make the most experienced local organizer easy to find, preserve institutional memory when a group dissolves, or make lessons from one movement accessible to another. Its job may be to maximize advertising revenue, engagement, subscriptions, transactions, or time spent on the service.
This is where O’Reilly’s distinction becomes especially useful.
A platform can begin by solving a navigation problem and later discover that controlling navigation itself is enormously valuable. Once you control the pathway between people and what they are trying to find, you have opportunities to capture some of the value moving through that pathway.
At Netcentric Campaigns, we have been thinking about part of our current civic problem as the privatizing and walling off of the gardens where civic connection happens. The issue is larger than any individual platform. Over time, parts of the civic commons have moved into systems whose owners determine the rules, visibility, access, and economics of participation.
That shift changes civic behavior.
People retreat into spaces they already understand. Organizations build separate lists and communications systems. Information that could be useful across a field gets trapped inside proprietary databases, private communities, institutional silos, and personal relationships. People increasingly rely on trusted individuals to filter an environment that has become too complicated to navigate directly.
The result is an odd combination of abundance and scarcity. We have more information than anyone can absorb, more opportunities to communicate, and more ways to form groups, yet finding the right information for a particular decision can remain difficult. People working on remarkably similar problems often remain unaware of one another, and learning generated inside one group can travel poorly to the next.
American civic life contains enormous value. Too much of the broader infrastructure still makes that value difficult to find and circulate.
The assembly problem
This leads to a third question that network builders confront constantly: can the network assemble what people contribute?
A healthy advocacy network gives us a useful picture of what successful assembly looks like.
No single person or organization needs to possess all of the expertise, relationships, information, and resources required to address a complex problem. In fact, trying to concentrate all of that capacity at the center usually creates its own limitations. A strong network can distribute knowledge and leadership across many people while still creating ways for those resources to find one another when they are needed.
One participant may understand a regulatory process. Another has relationships in a community. Someone else knows the technical science, the legal landscape, or the history of similar fights. A communications specialist can translate the issue for a broader audience. A local leader can recognize whether a proposed strategy will actually work in the place where the fight is happening.
The network becomes powerful when those people do not need to report to the same organization in order to contribute to the same outcome.
Good network infrastructure helps expertise remain distributed while making it accessible. It allows data and resources to move toward the edges where people can put them to use. It creates enough shared language and connective tissue for participants to locate one another, combine what they know, and act without requiring every decision or relationship to pass through a central authority.
This is the kind of value creation we have spent years working to support at Netcentric Campaigns. The goal is not to accumulate every useful resource inside our organization. The goal is to help build a system in which the people closest to the work can reach more of the network’s collective capacity.
Civic networks need this capability because the existence of resources does not guarantee collective power. An environmental justice group may understand a permitting process, a public health organization may know the health effects involved, a neighborhood group may know the people affected, a researcher may have the data, and a lawyer may understand the regulatory vulnerability. Unless those capacities can connect and assemble around the problem, they remain valuable but separate.
This is one reason civic ecosystems can feel simultaneously crowded and underpowered. There may be thousands of organizations and millions of people doing useful work while the connective capacity among them remains weak.
Local groups repeatedly solve versions of problems other communities will later encounter. Organizations commission research their neighbors do not know exists. Hard-earned lessons disappear when staff move on, useful data remains isolated in separate systems, and movements develop practices that do not travel easily across issue areas. National organizations can have scale with limited visibility into local conditions, while local organizations can hold deep knowledge with limited access to national resources.
From a network perspective, the problem is not a lack of value. The value is everywhere.
The problem is our ability to assemble it.
And once value cannot circulate easily among participants, institutions that control pieces of the infrastructure gain greater leverage over it. A large organization can become the place where information accumulates but does not leave. A funder can become the hub through which otherwise disconnected organizations relate to one another. A technology platform can own the social graph. A consulting firm can repeatedly collect learning from a field without that learning becoming a shared field resource.
None of these actors has to be malicious for the system to become extractive. Institutional incentives are often enough. Every organization has reasons to retain some of the value that passes through it, while the larger network has a different need: keeping enough of that value in circulation.
Civic organizations have to examine themselves too
It would be easy to make this an argument about technology companies and leave civic institutions on the virtuous side of the line.
Network experience makes that difficult.
The temptation to capture value appears anywhere someone controls an important node. Network managers can make themselves indispensable to every relationship instead of helping participants form relationships that no longer require the manager. Organizations can begin treating the people around them as constituencies they own. Coalitions can become more concerned with protecting their position than strengthening the work of participants. Funders can unintentionally reorganize a field around their own strategies because access to resources gives those strategies gravitational pull.
National organizations face their own version of the problem when they collect local stories, data, relationships, and credibility to strengthen advocacy while returning relatively little durable capacity to the communities that produced those assets in the first place.
These problems are uncomfortable precisely because they often appear inside institutions trying to do good work.
The question is not whether an organization benefits from a network. It should. Healthy exchange creates value in many directions.
The more useful test is whether the organization becomes stronger by making the network stronger, or whether it becomes stronger by pulling value out of the network and concentrating it inside the institution.
We have to apply that test to our own work at Netcentric Campaigns.
If we help convene a network and make ourselves necessary to every important relationship, we have created dependency. If people can find one another without us, share resources without us, form projects we did not initiate, transfer knowledge across organizational boundaries, and combine their capacity in ways we did not direct, the network is becoming more capable.
That can mean giving up some control. It can also be some of the clearest evidence that the work is succeeding.
An architecture of participation for civic life
Near the end of O’Reilly’s discussion, he returns to a phrase he has used for years: the architecture of participation.
His argument is that some systems become powerful because their design allows many people to contribute to and benefit from a larger whole. He has used the web and open source software as examples of architectures that created space for participation to spread.
That is a useful way to think about the civic challenge in front of us.
Networked Nation is an effort by Netcentric Campaigns to strengthen the connective infrastructure underneath civic life. The purpose is not to gather every organization into one giant coalition or put one institution at the center of American civic activity.
There are already enormous amounts of civic energy, experience, and institutional capacity in the system.
The challenge is helping more of that value move.
That means thinking about whether someone working on a problem in one community can find people who encountered the same problem somewhere else; whether useful practices can travel between movements without every organization joining the same institution; whether local knowledge can enter larger systems without being stripped from the relationships and communities that produced it; and whether organizations can build shared resources that remain available to the field rather than disappearing behind institutional boundaries.
It also means creating enough connective capacity that independent actors can coordinate when coordination is useful while preserving the autonomy that makes distributed systems resilient.
These are infrastructure questions involving communications, technology, relationships, governance, trust, common language, resource sharing, and the practical work of helping people navigate across institutional boundaries. They are also questions about ownership and power.
Every system makes choices, explicitly or otherwise, about where value accumulates.
That is true for an AI company, a social platform, an advocacy organization, and a civic network.
Keep the value moving
The strength of O’Reilly’s argument is that it gives us a fairly simple test for complicated systems.
What is the system creating for the people who participate in it, and what is it capturing from them?
Civic life needs institutions. It needs organizations with staff, money, expertise, infrastructure, and the ability to act. Some value will always accumulate inside those institutions because coordination itself requires resources.
But democratic society also depends on enough value continuing to circulate beyond them. Knowledge needs pathways across organizational boundaries. Relationships should multiply rather than remain locked inside institutions. Participation should leave people more capable than it found them, and local experience should become useful to others without losing the context that made it meaningful. When needs emerge, people and resources need ways to find each other, and independent actors need enough connective infrastructure to turn distributed capacity into shared power.
When those things happen, participation compounds. Each contribution increases what the network can offer the next participant.
When they do not, civic life can contain tremendous amounts of activity while slowly losing the connective tissue that makes all that activity useful.
That is the choice embedded in the design of our civic infrastructure. We can build systems that become more valuable as more people participate, with the benefits of participation continuing to circulate through the network. Or we can allow the systems that control access, attention, resources, and relationships to capture progressively more of the value people create.
A healthy civic network creates more value than it captures.
The work ahead is building the infrastructure that allows that value to keep moving.
Start a Conversation
If you are seeing valuable knowledge, relationships, or participation accumulate in your network without circulating as well as they should, or if you are trying to build infrastructure that gives participants more capacity than it asks them to surrender, we would like to hear what you are learning.
Netcentric Campaigns works with leaders and organizations to design, strengthen, and connect advocacy networks around complex social challenges. If the questions in this article resemble the ones emerging in your work, get in touch and start a conversation with us.
